States like California and Washington may demonstrate that their stricter rules improve driver safety. This could lead federal officials to reconsider their previous decision on limiting truck drivers’ weekly working hours to 40 and potentially grant waivers to these states.
California’s Meal and Rest Break (MRB) rules were overridden by federal law in a ruling on December 21, 2018. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration announced on Friday that it will consider waiver requests for that ruling. A similar ruling about Washington state’s MRB rules on November 17, 2020, will also be considered. Both of these choices were made by the government under Trump.
FMCSA to Consider Petitions for Waiver of California and Washington MRB Rules
The notice said petitions for waivers could be submitted anytime. FMCSA asks for petitions for waivers of California and Washington rulings to be submitted by November 13, 2023. The FMCSA publishes petitions for waivers and allows public comments on them.
Employers in California and Washington follow stricter MRB rules than government standards. California workers are entitled to a 30-minute dinner break if they work more than five hours. They are also entitled to another 30-minute meal break if they work 10 or more hours. Also, workers are given a 10-minute break for every four hours they work. Most of Washington’s rules are like these.
Teamsters Disagree with Washington Trucking Association’s Claim on MRB Rules
After eight hours of driving, drivers must take a 30-minute break, not on-duty time. However, the federal government’s hours-of-service rules will become more flexible for employers in September 2020. An on-duty or non-driving period will count as the required break.
The Teamsters disagreed with the Washington Trucking Association’s claim. They said the state’s MRB rules worsen safety by increasing the shortage of safe truck parking. They argued that drivers could spend more time searching for parking or parking in unsafe areas.
Teamsters and ATA Disagree on FMCSA’s Preemption Finding
The union said truck drivers face a threat. The threat arises from not taking rest breaks as allowed by federal law. The drivers fear consequences from their employers if they don’t finish a run on time or prioritize earning extra pay by pushing themselves.
When asked if they were going to ask FMCSA for permission, the Teamsters didn’t say right away.
The American Trucking Associations asked FMCSA to make a preemption finding. They think the agency’s recent move is bad for the flow of national freight and could cost companies money.
Chris Spear, the President and CEO of ATA, believes that having a singular, national standard of work rules for professional drivers is crucial for safety and the supply chain.
ATA and Scopelitis Transportation Consulting Support FMCSA’s Preemption of California and Washington MRB Rules
Rest breaks for drivers are already mandated by federal law. Unnecessary and duplicative state laws lack a safety basis. They are enforced through private lawsuits to extort the trucking industry. Opening the door to this spurious litigation once again would impair the safe and efficient movement of interstate goods.
ATA is fully prepared to oppose the effort that would result in a confusing patchwork of regulations. The Federation will leverage all of its resources to stop this in its tracks.
- Sean Garney, co-director of Scopelitis Transportation Consulting, agreed with what ATA said.
Garney said that the FMCSA’s decision to override the Meal and Rest Break rules in California and Washington was good for business and safety, according to a Freight reporting website. National companies are not required to follow different hours of service rules in each state. This generally makes managing hours of service easier.
21 States Have Meal and Rest Break Laws
The National Conference of State Legislatures states that 21 states have rules about meal and rest break times. California and Washington are among these states.
|States with meal and rest laws|
Source: National Conference of State Legislatures, 2019
FMCSA Outlines Requirements for Waiver Bids
FMCSA has asked that all bids for waivers include the following:
- The extent to which a state’s meal and rest break laws have affected the health and safety of truck drivers who transport goods within the state.
- If the applicant plans to do anything to reduce or fix any effect, including if the enforcement of state meal and rest break laws for interstate property-carrying truck drivers will cause more trucks to park on the side of the road because there aren’t enough truck parking spots.
- Whether the application plans to do anything to deal with or lessen the effect of a state’s regulation of meal and rest break rules on interstate truck drivers who carry goods, and if any such effect would weaken the national supply chain.
Contact Lading Logistics For Comprehensive Logistics Solutions
Overall, the rollbacks could provide more flexibility for trucking companies and drivers, potentially reducing costs and increasing efficiency. Lading Logistics is dedicated to staying up-to-date with the latest developments in the trucking industry. They offer a wide range of services, including:
- Freight forwarding
- Ocean, train, road, air, and container shipping
- Storage solutions
- Last-mile pickup and delivery
- Retail sales and distribution
- Trade automation services
By leveraging their expertise and resources, Lading Logistics aims to provide efficient and reliable logistics solutions for their clients.